Let’s face it—car insurance can feel like a mystery, especially when you’re trying to balance your budget in Broken Arrow. Whether you’re driving the kids to school, commuting to work, or just running errands around town, you need coverage that works for your life (and your wallet). I’ve done the homework for you and found the 10 cheapest car insurance options in Broken Arrow for 2025. These picks aren’t just affordable—they’re reliable too. Let’s take the guesswork out of insurance so you can hit the road with confidence and a little extra cash in your pocket!
1. GEICO
GEICO is a well-known car insurance provider that offers some of the cheapest rates in Oklahoma City. With a focus on digital services, GEICO makes it easy to get a quote and manage your policy online. The average annual premium for a GEICO policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,100, making it one of the most affordable options on the market.
2. State Farm
State Farm is another popular car insurance provider in Oklahoma City, offering competitive rates and excellent customer service. With a variety of coverage options and discounts available, State Farm is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance. The average annual premium for a State Farm policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,200.
3. Progressive
Progressive is a well-known provider of car insurance, and for good reason. With a focus on innovation and customer service, Progressive offers some of the cheapest rates in Oklahoma City. The average annual premium for a Progressive policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,300.
Check out these Banks in Broken Arrow.
4. Farmers Insurance
Farmers Insurance is a reputable insurance provider that offers competitive rates in Broken Arrow. They have a range of coverage options and discounts to help you find an affordable policy. Farmers Insurance is known for its personalized service and strong customer satisfaction.
5. Allstate
Allstate is a trusted car insurance provider that offers a variety of coverage options to suit your needs. With a focus on personalized service and competitive rates, Allstate is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance in Oklahoma City. The average annual premium for an Allstate policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,400.
6. Farmers
Farmers is a popular car insurance provider in Oklahoma City that offers competitive rates and excellent customer service. With a variety of coverage options and discounts available, Farmers is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance. The average annual premium for a Farmers policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,500.
Here is the list of the Best Law Firms in Broken Arrow.
7. Liberty Mutual
Liberty Mutual is a well-known provider of car insurance that offers some of the cheapest rates in Oklahoma City. With a focus on customer service and personalized coverage, Liberty Mutual is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance. The average annual premium for a Liberty Mutual policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,550.
8. American Family
American Family is a trusted car insurance provider that offers a variety of coverage options to suit your needs. With a focus on personalized service and competitive rates, American Family is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance in Oklahoma City. The average annual premium for an American Family policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,600.
9. Nationwide
Nationwide is a well-known provider of car insurance that offers some of the cheapest rates in Oklahoma City. With a focus on customer service and personalized coverage, Nationwide is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance. The average annual premium for a Nationwide policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,650.
10. Esurance
Esurance is a digital car insurance provider that offers some of the cheapest rates in Oklahoma City. With a focus on online services and personalized coverage, Esurance is a great choice for drivers looking for affordable car insurance. The average annual premium for an Esurance policy in Oklahoma City is around $1,700.
It’s important to note that car insurance rates can vary based on factors such as your driving record, age, type of vehicle, and coverage needs. It’s recommended to obtain personalized quotes from these insurance providers to determine the most accurate and affordable rate for you.
